What does Russian President Vladimir Putin believe about God? That’s a fascinating question the world can’t answer “with any certainty,” according to Mark Tooley, president of The Institute on Religion and Democracy.
After all, there’s a difference between what Putin says and what he does — and there’s strangely a great deal of uncertainty and confusion intermingled with both.
“He had a devoutly Christian mother and has worn a crucifix around his neck for most of his life,” Tooley told Faithwire. “Certainly, he has embraced the patronage of the Russian Orthodox Church and used it to advance his own political purposes domestically and internationally, but that is a centuries-long tradition for Russia.”
Tooley explained that Russian Orthodoxy, to the outside world, might seem to position Putin’s country to be in perfect alignment with Western religious ideals, though fundamental differences between the cultures reveal stark incompatibilities.
Russia's Brand of Christianity
Rather than spiritual compatriots, the Christian faith seen in many Western countries is radically different from the Russian rendition of self-described, government-aligned religiosity.
Watch Tooley explain what Putin might believe, Russia’s religious background, and why Ukraine is in the crosshairs:
“Russia is a longtime nemesis to the West, precisely because of its version of Christianity,” Tooley recently wrote in a World Magazine article. “Russian Orthodoxy for centuries saw itself as guardian of the true faith in contrast to Western Catholicism and Protestantism. Moscow, according to this lore, is the third Rome, the seat of the true Christendom, after Constantinople and the Roman Empire.”
Tooley argued this ideology even permeated the Soviet Union, despite its anti-religious bent, and has colored certain aspects of how Russia views Ukraine today.
The religion expert affirmed, “Russian Orthodoxy has nearly always been a cheerleading nationalist subordinate to the state.” Despite Russia’s penchant for state-sponsored religion, he believes the nation “is more secular than many Western countries,” which might be surprising to some.
Despite the Soviet Union’s initial attempts to kill religion, its political usefulness was eventually recognized, Tooley said. And today, that persists.
Putin Sees Himself as a 'Messianic Figure'
With all this in mind, it’s easy to see why Putin and the state are so interested in religion, particularly when it comes to Ukraine. Harry Farley of the BBC recently said Putin views himself as a “messianic figure, a savior, to reunite Eastern Orthodox churches under Moscow.”
Russia's Vladimir Putin crosses himself while bathing in the icy water in -4 degrees Fahrenheit temperatures during an Epiphany celebration near Moscow, Jan. 19, 2021. Water that is blessed by a cleric on Epiphany is believed to have special powers of protection and healing. (Mikhail Klimentyev, Sputnik, Kremlin Pool Photo via AP)
The theological circumstances in Ukraine and Russia become increasingly concerning when considering the Orthodox Church in Ukraine was granted autonomy just three years ago, freeing itself from Russian control.
Despite a portion of the Orthodox church in Ukraine still recognizing Russian authority, the schism has grown.
“The Orthodox Church in Ukraine, just three years ago, gained its autonomy, and its chief bishop was recognized by the Patriarch of Constantinople as having his own distinct authority, no longer subordinate to the patriarch of Moscow,” Tooley explained. “Which, obviously, the Russian church and the Russian state did not like.”
#PRAYFORUKRAINE: Join CBN News Senior International Correspondent George Thomas, and his special guest—a Ukrainian pastor—in an exclusive LIVE CBN News Prayer Event! Saturday, March 5, 2022 at 11:00 a.m. EST
There’s a complex history surrounding these issues, but historian Katherine Kelaidis has explained the Patriarch of Constantinople, who has claimed the mantle of leadership for Orthodoxy, is more aligned with the West, whereas the Patriarch of Moscow, who heads the Russian Church, has a more traditional stance, along with other distinctions.
Regardless of finer points of the history, know this: the Ukrainian Church’s decision to split in 2018 was seen as “historic.” At the time, former Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko praised the move.
“This day will go down in history as a sacred day … the day of the final independence from Russia,” he said.
What Happens Next?
It’s unclear what would happen if Russia took complete control of Ukraine. However, it is possible — even likely — the Russian Orthodox Church would attempt to regain control over its Ukrainian counterpart.
Putin has repeatedly made clear he views Ukraine and Russia as sharing a “spiritual space.” Thus, this issue presumably hasn’t left the forefront of the radical leader’s mind.
“Ukraine is not just a neighboring country for us,” he recently said. “It is an inalienable part of our own history, culture, and spiritual space.”
Now, let’s reconsider how these connections and Putin’s pining for control over the Ukrainian people comport with his personal religious practices. Farley offered a compelling recap, shedding some light on Putin’s perspective.
“Moscow and the Russian Orthodox Church developed, became this huge power … within the Orthodox Church. But in 2019, the Ukrainian Orthodox Church split off from Russia and was recognized as independent,” he said. “Religion is hugely important for Putin’s identity, for his psyche. He immerses himself in icy water to mark the festival of Epiphany, he wears his baptismal cross.”
What Does Putin Really Believe?
This brings us back to our original question: What does Putin believe about God? Again, it’s unclear.
Despite speaking about faith and spiritual issues — and taking part in religious rituals — the Russian leader has been remiss at moments to say what he believes specifically. In fact, he was infamously ambiguous on the matter in a 2007 Time Magazine interview.
The outlet told Putin many Americans view Russia as a “godless country.” Highlighting how Putin has often discussed faith, Time then asked, “What role does faith play in your own leadership, and what role should faith play in government and in the public sphere?” The Russian leader’s response was measured.
“First and foremost, we should be governed by common sense, but common sense should be based on moral principles first,” he said. “And it is not possible today to have morality separated from religious values. I will not expand, as I don’t want to impose my views on people who have different viewpoints.”
In a follow-up question, Putin was asked if he believes in a “Supreme God,” and he shot back, “Do you?” He then declined to share his specific beliefs on the matter.
“There are things I believe, which should not, in my position, at least, be shared with the public at large for everybody’s consumption, because that would look like self-advertising or a political striptease,” he said.
The mysteries around Putin persist as his brutal invasion of Ukraine marches on. While the motives and internal beliefs might not be obvious, understanding the Orthodox divide gives a lens into a sliver of the overarching battle.
***As the number of voices facing big-tech censorship continues to grow, please sign up for Faithwire’s daily newsletter and download the CBN News app, to stay up-to-date with the latest news from a distinctly Christian perspective.***